The Broadway Album
Barbra Streisand
1985: CBS CK 40092
This is the only Streisand album I own, therefore I am not a proper queen. Don’t get me wrong: I think she’s a great singer, and I LOVE her in “What’s Up, Doc?” but I just don’t revel in her albums. I just happened to be so smitten by a couple of tracks on this particular one that I added it to my collection. Specifically “Being Alive” (because it’s a great song horribly tainted by its Original Broadway Cast recording[s]), “Somewhere,” and “The Ladies Who Lunch.” Since I added this to my collection, I’ve come to cherish a couple of other tracks: “If I Loved You,” thanks to the “recording of” video for this album, which really recast the song for me in such a way that I actually appreciate it now, and the Porgy & Bess pair (in which case I have always been repulsed by the dialect-heavy lyrics, but Babs’s rendition reacquainted me with the gorgeous harmonic sequences Gershwin wrote under it all).
I have mixed feelings about her commandeering of Sondheim’s “Putting It Together,” although I concede that she not only got the master himself to revise the lyrics for her and she did pull it into a valid and compelling version. That her delivery of it actually gives me chills (not just the first time, which is, what, ten years ago?) is testimony.
Overall the album’s dreadfully handicapped and dated by cheesy synth-keyboard elements on many tracks, and it’s not helped by Streisand’s indifference to written tempo of melody (one of the main reasons I have never been able to enjoy her work despite her voice’s copious merits). What’s really sad is that her version of “Being Alive,” full of syn-drums and almost-disco Vegas-snazziness, is still better than the versions recorded by the Original Broadway Cast.
Comments © 2005 Mark Ellis Walker, except as noted, and no claim is made to the images and quoted lyrics.